Verbal And Nominal Agreement In Portuguese Mastering Tricky Grammar Questions

by ADMIN 78 views

Hey guys! Ever feel like grammar questions are designed to trip you up? You're not alone! Let's dive into one of those tricky questions today, focusing on verbal and nominal agreement, and break down why some sentences just sound...off. We'll use a specific example to illustrate, but the principles we cover will help you tackle tons of similar questions. So, buckle up, grammar nerds!

The Dreaded Question

Our example question is a classic: "Assinale a alternativa que contenha um período em que a concordância verbal ou nominal está incorreta: Em 1827 houveram um grande número de discussões sobre o fato de que os professores deveriam ensinar a ler e a escrever utilizando a gramática da..."

Sounds intimidating, right? Let's simplify it. This question is asking us to find the sentence where either the verb doesn't agree with its subject (verbal agreement) or the nouns and adjectives don't match up correctly (nominal agreement). The specific sentence given mentions 1827 and a large number of discussions about teaching methods. Our mission is to figure out if everything in that sentence is grammatically sound. To do this effectively, we need to understand the core principles of both verbal and nominal agreement.

Verbal Agreement Unveiled

Verbal agreement, at its heart, is about matching the verb to the subject in terms of number (singular or plural) and person (first, second, or third). Think of it as a grammatical dance where the verb and subject move in harmony. If the subject is singular, the verb needs to be singular. If the subject is plural, the verb must be plural. Seems simple enough, but tricky sentences can throw in curveballs, like collective nouns or compound subjects. For instance, a sentence like "The team is playing well" uses the singular verb "is" because "team" is treated as a single unit here. However, if we said, "The team members are disagreeing," we'd use the plural verb "are" because we're focusing on the individual members. Let's consider the question, "Em 1827 houveram um grande número de discussões..." The verb here is "houveram," which is the third-person plural past tense of "haver" (to have or to exist). Now, what's the subject? The phrase "um grande número de discussões" (a large number of discussions) is the key. Because "discussões" (discussions) is plural, many might think "houveram" is correct. However, the verb "haver" used in the sense of "existir" (to exist) is impersonal and should remain in the singular, even when referring to a plural quantity. This is a common point of confusion in Portuguese grammar. The correct form would be "houve um grande número de discussões..." (there was a large number of discussions). This highlights the importance of identifying the grammatical subject and understanding the specific rules that apply to certain verbs like "haver."

Nominal Agreement Demystified

Nominal agreement is all about ensuring that nouns, adjectives, pronouns, and articles all play nice together in terms of gender (masculine or feminine) and number (singular or plural). It's like a grammatical color palette where everything needs to match to create a harmonious picture. If you have a feminine singular noun, the adjective describing it, the article preceding it, and any pronouns referring to it also need to be feminine singular. For example, "a casa branca" (the white house) demonstrates nominal agreement perfectly: "a" (the) is feminine singular, "casa" (house) is feminine singular, and "branca" (white) is also feminine singular. A common mistake is mismatching these elements, such as saying "o casa branca" (the white house) which incorrectly uses the masculine singular article "o" with the feminine noun "casa." To master nominal agreement, pay close attention to the gender and number of the noun and make sure all related words follow suit. In longer sentences, this can get tricky, especially with multiple adjectives describing a single noun or with pronouns that have distant referents. But the fundamental principle remains the same: everything has to agree! Looking back at our original sentence, we don't see any glaring issues with nominal agreement. Phrases like "um grande número de discussões" are grammatically correct in terms of gender and number. However, the verbal agreement error overshadows any potential nominal hiccups in this particular sentence.

Back to the Question The Answer Revealed

Okay, let's circle back to our original question. We've dissected the core concepts of verbal and nominal agreement. Now, we can confidently pinpoint the error in the sentence: "Em 1827 houveram um grande número de discussões..." The verb "houveram" is incorrectly used here. As we discussed, the impersonal verb "haver" should be in the singular form ("houve") when it means "to exist." Therefore, the correct sentence should be: "Em 1827 houve um grande número de discussões..."

Why This Matters The Bigger Picture

Why do we even bother with these grammar rules? Well, beyond scoring points on a test, correct grammar is crucial for clear communication. When verbal and nominal agreement are off, it can create confusion and make your writing or speech sound awkward. Imagine reading a sentence where the verb seems to be randomly chosen, or where adjectives and nouns clash in gender and number. It's jarring, right? Mastering these concepts allows you to express yourself with precision and confidence. Think of it as building a solid foundation for your language skills. The better you understand the rules, the more effectively you can communicate your ideas. Plus, a strong grasp of grammar will boost your credibility in academic, professional, and even social settings. People tend to perceive those who use correct grammar as more educated and competent. So, investing the time to learn these rules is an investment in yourself and your future.

Pro Tips for Conquering Agreement Questions

So, you're armed with the knowledge, but how do you tackle these questions strategically? Here are some pro tips:

  • Identify the Verb and Subject: The first step in any verbal agreement question is to pinpoint the verb and its subject. Ask yourself, "Who or what is performing the action?" Once you've identified them, make sure they agree in number and person.
  • Look for Impersonal Verbs: Be especially wary of impersonal verbs like "haver" (in the sense of "to exist"), which often trip people up. Remember, they stay in the singular form.
  • Break Down the Sentence: Complex sentences can be overwhelming. Break them down into smaller chunks to analyze the relationships between words more easily.
  • Spot the Noun: For nominal agreement questions, identify the main noun and then check if all the surrounding adjectives, articles, and pronouns match in gender and number.
  • Read Aloud: Sometimes, your ear can catch errors that your eye might miss. Reading the sentence aloud can help you identify awkward phrasing or incorrect agreements.
  • Practice, Practice, Practice: The more you practice, the better you'll become at spotting these errors. Work through practice questions and pay attention to the explanations.

Final Thoughts

Grammar questions might seem daunting, but they're totally conquerable with a solid understanding of the rules and a bit of practice. Remember, verbal and nominal agreement are all about creating harmony in your sentences. So, embrace the challenge, hone your skills, and watch your language skills soar! You got this, guys!

Keywords: verbal agreement, nominal agreement, grammar, Portuguese, sentences, subject, verb, noun, adjective, gender, number, impersonal verbs, practice questions, grammar rules, communication, clear communication.